Nitrogen cycling networks of coastal ecosystems: influence of trophic status and primary producer form

We have used ecological network analysis to compare nitrogen cycles from five well-researched coastal ecosystems. These included a representative ricefield and two lagoons (Tancada and Encanysada lagoons) in the Ebro River delta, Spain; a region of the Sacca di Goro, a lagoon at the mouth of the Po River, Italy; and a drowned river estuary in North Carolina, USA, the Neuse River estuary. We constructed networks for the various systems and ranked them by trophic status (i.e., degree of eutrophication) using four indices. We then considered the importance of (1) trophic status, (2) growth form of dominant primary producer and (3) water residence time to the intensity and pattern of recycling and to the manner in which the systems can “filter” N. Three indices of flux (rate of import, primary producivity and total systems throughput) gave similar rankings of trophic status among ecosystems with the Italian and U.S. systems being most eutrophic, ricefields next, and then the two Spanish lagoons. Patterns of N export and of cycling within the systems were most closely related to the growth form of dominant primary producers. Phytoplankton, with their rapid turnover rate, foster rapid recycling within the water column and continuous transfer to sediments and export. Submersed and emergent aquatic vegetation and macroalgae create lags and pulses within systems by sequestering N during growth and releasing it during senescence, death and decomposition. Trends in cycling among systems relative to trophic status or water residence appear largely secondary to primary producer growth form.