Achievement goals and academic achievement: A closer look at moderating factors

•Meta-analysis investigating associations between achievement goals and achievement.•Several important moderators were analyzed in detail.•Due to the respective achievement goal different moderators were identified.•Important moderators were the specific achievement outcome and measurement issues. Two recently published meta-analyses (Huang, 2012; Hulleman, Schrager, Bodmann, & Harackiewicz, 2010) have focused on the association between achievement goals and achievement outcomes. These meta-analyses differed to some extent, e.g., regarding the identified moderators. The present meta-analysis serves to clarify those heterogeneous findings by considering more studies through 2011 and by considering more moderators. Our literature search identified 180 publications (N=81 947). Analyses (using random effects models) revealed small but significant associations between achievement goals and achievement outcomes (r=−.12 to r=.13; all ps.05). The results of the present moderator analyses differed from those of the previous meta-analyses. For example, in contrast to Huang (2012), we were able to find several moderators of the association between performance-approach goals and academic achievement. The results have several important implications, especially regarding the assessment of achievement goals.