Toxicopathic hepatic lesions as biomarkers of chemical contaminant exposure and effects in marine bottomfish species from the Northeast and Pacific Coasts, USA

Relationships between toxicopathic hepatic lesions and chemical contaminants in sediments, stomach contents, liver and bile were evaluated in English sole, starry flounder and white croaker from 27 sites on the Pacific Coast, and winter flounder from 22 sites on the Northeast Coast of the USA, as part of the NOAA's National Benthic Surveillance Program (NBSP). Prevalences of and relative risks for most toxicopathic lesions were significantly higher in fish from contaminated sites in Puget Sound, the Los Angeles area, and San Francisco and San Diego Bays on the Pacific Coast, and in Boston Harbor, Raritan Bay and certain urban sites in Long Island Sound on the Northeast Coast. Exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), PCBs, DDTs, chlordanes and dieldrin were significant risk factors for all lesion types in Pacific Coast species. In winter flounder from the Northeast Coast, exposure to PAHs, DDTs or chlordanes were significant risk factors only for hydropic vacuolation, nonneoplastic proliferative and nonspecific necrotic lesions, and less commonly for neoplasms and foci of cellular alteration. Risk of hepatic disease generally increased with fish age, but sex was rarely a risk factor. Temporal trends analyses of hepatic lesion prevalences in starry flounder, white croaker and English sole from NBSP sites on the Pacific Coast failed to detect any significant monotonic increases or decreases in lesion prevalence. Recent studies utilized a two-segment ‘hockey-stick’ regression technique applied to NBSP data to determine threshold levels of sediment PAHs, which are clearly associated with toxicopathic hepatic lesions in English sole. Significant chemical threshold levels for these lesions are in the vicinity of 500–1000 ppb ΣPAHs in sediment, values considerably lower than those reported for other techniques. Application of this dose-response model to these subacute and chronic lesions involved in hepatocarcinogenesis, provides nonlethal sediment quality assessment endpoints for contaminant concentrations that may have long term health implications for chronically exposed native fish populations. Overall, these relationships provide strong evidence for environmental contaminants as etiologic agents for hepatic lesions in several marine bottomfish species, and clearly indicate their utility as biomarkers of contaminant-induced effects in wild fish, whether in national and regional biomonitoring programs or within the injury assessment phase of the leg