Hierarchical multilevel analysis of increased caseload volume and postoperative outcome after elective colorectal surgery

Background The study aimed to explore the impact of surgeon and institution volume on outcome following colorectal surgery in England using multilevel hierarchical analysis. Methods An observational study design was used. All patients undergoing primary elective colorectal resection between 2000 and 2008 were included from the Hospital Episode Statistics database. Consultant surgeons and hospitals were divided into tertiles (low, medium and high volume) according to their mean annual colorectal cancer resection caseload. Outcome measures examined were postoperative 30‐day mortality, 28‐day readmission and reoperation, and length of stay. Hierarchical multiple regression analysis adjusted for age, sex, co‐morbidity, social deprivation, year of surgery, operation type and surgical approach. Results A total of 109 261 elective cancer colorectal resections were included. High‐volume consultant surgeons and hospitals were defined as performing more than 20·7 and 103·5 elective colorectal cancer procedures per year respectively. Consultant and hospital operative volumes increased throughout the study period. In hierarchical regression models, greater surgeon and institutional volume independently predicted only shorter length of hospital stay. No statistical association was observed between higher provider volume and postoperative mortality, 28‐day reoperation or readmission rates. Conclusion Increasing elective colorectal cancer caseload alone may have marginal postoperative benefit. Defines volume‐outcome statistics