A Comparative Performance Evaluation of Mainstream Multiphase Models for Aerated Flow on Stepped Spillways

A systematic comparative evaluation of mainstream multiphase models for specific hydraulic structures is essential to investigate aerated flow characteristics and promote the models’ application. However, such evaluations remain scarce. In this paper, four multiphase models, namely the VOF, Mixture, and Eulerian models in Ansys Fluent and the aerated flow model in FLOW-3D (AFM-F3D), were comparatively introduced and tested for the aerated flow over stepped spillways. Simulation results, including water surface profiles, inception points of aeration, air concentrations, velocities, and turbulent kinetic energies from four models, are compared with each other and with available experimental data. It is discovered that both the VOF and Mixture models fail to reproduce the self-aeration and subsequent downward transport phenomenon. In contrast, AFM-F3D and the Eulerian models predict reliable aerated water surface profiles. AFM-F3D and the Eulerian model demonstrate superior performance in velocity and air concentration calculations, respectively. Based on overall performance, the Eulerian model is recommended for simulating aerated stepped spillway flows. These insights provide valuable guidance for selecting appropriate multiphase models based on specific engineering requirements.