Chaos, phase transitions and curvature invariants of (rotating, warped, massive) BTZ black holes

Combining several results from the previous works of the author, three main subtleties will be clarified here. First, similar to the rotating BTZ black holes, we show how for the warped BTZ black holes, the consideration of the effective temperatures could solve the seemingly unsaturation issue of the chaos bound. Second, comparing the Hawking-Page phase diagrams of BTZ and warped BTZ black holes in the topologically massive gravity and new massive gravity theories, we show how the characteristics of the action would specify the behaviors of the chaos modes, and there we emphasize the importance of using the local and “physical” thermodynamical ensembles for studying the boundary chaos modes in warped CFTs and also the connections with the bulk reconstruction. Third, we propose that the boundary modular scrambling modes which saturate the modular chaos bound are related to the curvature invariants in the geometrical side.