Individual behavioral variability across time and contexts in Dendrobates tinctorius poison frogs

Consistent individual differences in behavior (“animal personality”) have consequences for individual fitness, evolutionary trajectories, and species’ persistence. Such differences have been documented across a wide range of animals, though amphibians are generally underrepresented in this research area. The aim of our study was to examine consistent individual differences in Dyeing poison frogs, Dendrobates tinctorius . We evaluated repeatability in activity, exploration, and boldness to assess consistency of behaviors across different temporal, experimental, and environmental contexts. We found repeatability in activity and exploration across time and contexts. In contrast, we observed context-specific behavior for our metrics of boldness, with consistent individual differences only for some measures. Further, while activity and exploration displayed consistent correlations across contexts, relationships between activity and boldness were context dependent. Our findings document the presence of consistent individual differences in behavior in D. tinctorius poison frogs, and also reveal context-dependent behavioral differences, highlighting the complex relationship between consistent individual differences and context-specific responses in animal behavior. Significance statement The concept of animal personality centers on the existence of consistent individual differences in behavior. However, behavioral responses can depend on context, and consistent individual differences in one context do not guarantee consistent differences in another. To address this question, we assessed activity, exploration, and boldness in captive-bred poison frogs ( Dendrobates tinctorius ) across time and environmental contexts. Our comprehensive approach revealed consistent individual differences in some behaviors and context-specificity in others. While activity and exploration were generally repeatable and correlated with one another, boldness was not. Especially in view of the emphasis on measures of boldness in the animal personality literature, our findings emphasize the importance of reiterative and holistic approaches in the study of animal behavior.