Co-limitation of Fine Root Growth by Nitrogen and Phosphorus in Early Successional Northern Hardwood Forests

Functional balance theory predicts that plants will allocate less carbon belowground when the availability of nutrients is elevated. We tested this prediction in two successional northern hardwood forest stands by quantifying fine root biomass and growth after 5–7 years of treatment in a nitrogen (N) x phosphorus (P) factorial addition experiment. We quantified root responses at two different levels of treatment: the whole-plot scale fertilization and small-patch scale fertilization of ingrowth cores. Fine root biomass was higher in plots receiving P, and fine root growth was highest in plots receiving both N and P. Thus, belowground productivity did not decrease in response to long-term addition of nutrients. We did not find conclusive evidence that elevated availability of one nutrient at the plot scale induced foraging for the other nutrient at the core scale, or that foraging for nutrients at the core scale responded to addition of limiting nutrients. Our observations suggest NP co-limitation of fine root growth and indicate complex interactions of N and P affecting aboveground and belowground production in early successional northern hardwood forest ecosystems.