An Earlier Spring Phenology Reduces Vegetation Growth Rate during the Green-Up Period in Temperate Forests

Climatic warming advances the start of the growing season (SOS) and sequentially enhances the vegetation productivity of temperate forests by extending the carbon uptake period and/or increasing the growth rate. Recent research indicates that the vegetation growth rate is a main driver for the interannual changes in vegetation carbon uptake; however, the specific effects of an earlier SOS on vegetation growth rate and the underlying mechanisms are still unclear. Using 268 year-site PhenoCam observations in temperate forests, we found that an earlier SOS reduced the vegetation growth rate and mean air temperature during the green-up period (i.e., from the SOS to the peak of the growing period), but increased the accumulation of shortwave radiation during the green-up period. Interestingly, an earlier-SOS-induced reduction in the growth rate was weakened in the highly humid areas (aridity index ≥ 1) when compared with that in the humid areas (aridity index < 1), suggesting that an earlier-SOS-induced reduction in the growth rate in temperate forests may intensify with the ongoing global warming and aridity in the future. The structural equation model analyses indicated that an earlier-SOS-induced decrease in the temperature and increase in shortwave radiation drove a low vegetation growth rate. Our findings highlight that the productivity of temperate forests may be overestimated if the negative effect of an earlier SOS on the vegetation growth rate is ignored.