Low seed fertility of hermaphrodites is maintained in a gynodioecious species throughout the distribution range in Japan

Dioecy, the separation of sex at the individual level, evolved in angiosperms from hermaphroditic ancestors. One of the postulated evolutionary pathways is by way of the gynodioecious stage, i.e., the coexistence of female and hermaphroditic individuals. In a morphologically gynodioecious species, Daphne jezoensis., seed fertility in hermaphrodites is limited compared to that of females, indicating that its sexual system is close to dioecy. The aim of this study was to clarify whether the gynodioecy in this species is a stable sexual system or a transitional state leading to dioecy. We evaluated variations in the degree of pollen limitation, sexual and mating systems, floral morphology, sex ratio, and the genetic structure of 14 populations across the species’distribution range in Japan. Sexual systems were similar among populations throughout the distribution range although the southernmost populations had unique genetic structures to some extent. Hermaphrodites were commonly self-compatible, but their fruiting capacity was low in every population. This suggests that gynodioecy composed of females and hermaphrodites having low seed fertility is a consistent sexual system in D. jezoensis. Low seed fertility in hermaphrodites throughout the distribution range suggests that this sexual system is not necessarily a transitional state from gynodioecy to dioecy if occasional seed production in hermaphrodites has any advantage. One possible ecological advantage for the maintenance of hermaphrodites is that seed production by autonomous self-pollination may be beneficial in the colonization process after long-distance seed dispersal.