Niche determinants in a salamander complex: Does hybridism or reproductive parasitism explain patterns of distribution?

Organisms with multiple biotic attributes may also have conflicting niche determinants, and we assessed whether the realized niche reflects single or multiple biotic attributes. A group of all‐female salamanders found in eastern North America (unisexual salamanders; Ambystoma spp.) embody two potentially competing biotic states: hybridism and obligate reproductive parasitism. In theory, hybrids should occupy areas that are transitional to those used by parental species, parasites must live in syntopy with their hosts, and parasites that engage in ecological competition with hosts should be most successful in habitats that are moderately suitable for hosts. We built niche models for bisexual salamanders (Ambystoma laterale and Ambystoma jeffersonianum), as well as for unisexual Ambystoma that posses nuclear DNA from both of these species. These unisexuals are both phenotypic hybrids and obligate reproductive parasites of the bisexual species. We characterized realized niches predicted for unisexual Ambystoma via a hybrid‐framework model (e.g., using environmental predictors) and a parasite‐framework model (e.g., using host suitability predictors). Model validation using ancillary data permitted evaluation of which biotic state (hybrid vs. parasite) fit the observed patterns of occupancy. The hybrid model conformed strongly with predictions that the unisexual niche would be transitional between A. laterale and A. jeffersonianum bisexuals. Average annual temperatures and terrestrial salamander species richness (a proxy for competition) were particularly descriptive of parental niches and hybrid occupancy of transitional environments. While the parasite model behaved as expected, model validation did not fully corroborate its utility for determining patterns of occupancy. Instead, model selection revealed that the hybrid model was more descriptive of unisexual occurrence than the parasite model. Despite the fundamental importance of reproductive parasitism to the persistence of unisexual Ambystoma, we suggest that hybridism has greater contribution to the realized niche. When species have competing ecological attributes, one primary biotic state may dominate as a determinant of the realized niche.