Species-specific size vulnerabilities in a competitive arena: Nutrient heterogeneity and soil fertility alter plant competitive size asymmetries

The size dependence of competitive interactions is starting to be highlighted as an important driver of species diversity within communities; however, it is still unknown whether all species are equally impacted by size‐asymmetric competition and what resources drive it. Here, we test species‐specific responses to size‐asymmetric competition under various soil environments by manipulating plant size as well as soil fertility, nutrient heterogeneity and the initial suppression of microbial communities within a three‐species community. Competition was primarily size‐asymmetric; however, the degree to which competition was size‐asymmetric was species‐specific, where three out of five soil treatments resulted in size‐asymmetric competition in some species but size‐symmetric competition in others. Overall, soil fertility and nutrient heterogeneity altered the degree of size‐asymmetric competition, while the initial suppression of microbial communities had no effect. Contrary to past predictions, when they had an effect, increased soil fertility and the presence of a high‐quality patch reduced the degree of size‐asymmetric competition, while the presence of a low‐quality patch increased it. This suggests that the role nutrient heterogeneity plays on the degree of size‐asymmetric competition is dependent on the quality and location of the patch relative to an individual's neighbours. These findings challenge the current understanding that competition for soil resources is always size‐symmetric and demonstrate that species within the same community may not experience the same degree of size‐dependent competition. These differential responses suggest we must consider variations in tolerance and suppression between species during size‐dependent plant–plant interactions, which may promote species coexistence as all small individuals may not be negatively impacted during size‐dependent competition. A plain language summary is available for this article. Plain Language Summary