Lessons Learned From a Regional System Blackout and Restoration in BC Hydro

A BC Hydro regional system experienced a blackout after multiple 500 kV lines, sharing the same transmission corridor, were subjected to lightning strikes in the time span of about three minutes. These lines connect two large generating stations, regional loads, and five nonutility generators to the rest of the BC Hydro system. The protection scheme on the first line tripped three-phase and initiated autoreclose as designed. However immediately after three-phase opening, high magnitudes of low-frequency (about 9 Hz) currents appeared in the line shunt reactor, causing a protection trip, and aborting the autoreclose. Subsequent lightning strikes coupled with a pre-existing line outage disconnected both generating stations from each other as well as from the integrated system. The larger of two generating stations and almost all regional load formed an islanded subsystem, which eventually collapsed and blacked out. During the restoration of the subsystem, the system operator inadvertently picked up the entire regional system without load, causing steady-state resonant overvoltages higher than 145% and damaging a transmission customer. This paper shares lessons learned from forensic analysis of disturbances leading to regional blackout and describes the risk of unsafe overvoltages from near power frequency resonant condition during the restoration process.