Closed-end funds and sentiment risk

Irradional noise traders earn high returns for bearing risk that they themselves create. Diversifying across closed-end funds does little to reduce this risk, because discounts are correlated across funds. But diversification between closed-end funds and large-cap stocks does reduce this risk, especially when markets are not subject to major shocks: a combination of closed-end funds and large-cap stocks has lower risk than either one alone. To the extent that fund shares and large-cap stocks are partially segmented markets, large-cap stocks thus provide some protection against the sentiment risk created by noise traders. This paper estimates the amount of large-cap stocks needed in tax-deferred portfolios, under various amounts of market-wide risk, and ways of measuring it.