Neuropsychological Functioning of Opiate-Dependent Patients: A Nonrandomized Comparison of Patients Preferring either Buprenorphine or Methadone Maintenance Treatment

Objectives: In the present study, we investigated whether buprenorphine as a partial μ -opioid receptor agonist is associated with less cognitive impairment than methadone. Methods: Neuropsychological functioning of opioid-dependent patients, previously assigned to methadone (MMP, n = 30) or buprenorphine (BMP, n = 26) maintenance treatment according to their own preference, was compared and dose effects were investigated. Results: MMP and BMP performed equally well on all measures of neuropsychological functioning including the trail making test, the continuous performance test, and a vigilance task. However, patients receiving a higher dose of methadone were impaired in a vigilance task. Conclusions: In a free-choice administration of methadone or buprenorphine, there seems to be no difference in cognitive functioning. Possible explanations are discussed.