On the liquid–liquid phase transition of dense hydrogen

Until recently the consensus theory/computation interpretation of the challenging liquid liquid phase transition (LLPT) of high-pressure hydrogen was first order. Cheng et al. developed a machine-learnt potential (MLP) that, in larger molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, gives a continuous transition instead. Here, we show that the MLP does not reproduce our still larger MD density-functional theory (MD-DFT) calculations as it should. Since the MLP is not a faithful surrogate for the MD-DFT, the Ref. 6 prediction of a supercritical atomic liquid is unfounded.