Comment on "Boson Peak in Deeply Cooled Confined Water: A Possible Way to Explore the Existence of the Liquid-to-Liquid Transition in Water"

In their Letter, Wang et al. report on an inelastic neutron scattering (INS) experiment where they describe the pressure evolution of a low energy (E ~ 6 meV) excitation, emerging in confined protonated water only below 230 K at an exchanged momentum Q=2.0 Å-1. Also, water confinement was used to overcome the unavoidable crystallization occurring below ~250 K in bulk water. The authors report that a similar finding was also obtained in both bulk (numerical simulations) and confined water at ambient pressure. They refer to this low temperature excitation as a boson peak (BP), and relate its occurrence to the Widom line, concluding that the observed pressure behavior of the BP reveals the signature of the high-density liquid (HDL) to the low-density liquid (LDL) transition proposed, though severely questioned, for bulk water. Lastly, we believe these claims to be unconvincing for the following reasons.