Mitigation of High Lateral Asymmetry Rates Due to Loss of a Cruise Motor on the X-57 Mod III Aircraft

The X-57 Mod III aircraft utilizes wingtip electric motors to generate thrust. The potential benefit of wingtip propulsion is a reduction in induced drag because wingtip vortices are interrupted. Wingtip propulsors, however, pose the risk of dangerous thrust asymmetry if one of the motors abruptly stops producing full thrust. This paper examines the effects of a full-power, single-motor failure at various phases of flight for the X-57 Mod III aircraft design by way of piloted-in-the-loop simulations conducted by two National Aeronautics and Space Administration test pilots. After determining that a failure during takeoff potentially poses the highest risk of catastrophic consequences, possible mitigations to the failure were explored and evaluated through pilot simulation data, Cooper-Harper ratings, and pilot comments. The preferred mitigation was found to be an automated power reduction system that allowed for a lower pilot workload and quick reduction of the asymmetric thrust.