Looking Again at Clarity in Philosophy: Writing as a Shaper and Sharpener of Thought

Bryan Magee's recent paper 'Clarity in Philosophy' argues that instead of focusing on clarity at the sentence level, writers should emphasize formulating their ideas clearly before any writing takes place. In part using text-analysis of three well-known philosophers, I will uphold Magee's assertion that clear writing is not necessary in order to be considered a great philosopher. On the other hand, I will challenge his ideas regarding the relationship between language and cognition by reflecting on ways in which writing aids the development of ideas.