The effect of early human contact and the separation method from the dam on responses of beef calves to humans

The objectives of this experiment were to evaluate the effect of early human contact and of the separation method from the dam on the future relationships of calves with humans, and to investigate the relationship between dam responses and calf responses. Thirty-three Salers calves aged 2–4 days old and reared outdoors were split into 3-week treatments balanced according to sex and birth dates. Group 1 (long separation from the dam and human contact: LS + H; n = 11) underwent 8 h of separation from the dam per day and 5 min of individual stroking; group 2 (short separation from the dam and human contact: SS + H; n = 11) underwent 1 h of separation and the same amount of human contact as LS + H calves. Group 3 (short separation from the dam and no human contact: SS − H; n = 11) was a control group undergoing the same duration of separation as SS + H but without stroking. At 3, 15 and 45 weeks of age, the calves were tested in a standard arena test (AT) where they were successively left alone (2 min), left with a stationary human (5 min), and left with a human approaching and touching them (2 min). At 15 and 45 weeks, the calves were also tested with the standard docility test (DT: test of restraint). The dams were also tested with DT 2 months before calving. Data analysis via Mann–Whitney tests and Spearman's correlations showed no significant effect of the duration calves were separated from their dams. Just after treatment at 3-week of age, calves given stroking (LS + H and SS + H) were more motionless and more willing to accept human contact (AT: touching) than control calves (SS − H, P < 0.01). At 45 weeks of age, calves given stroking spent also significantly more time ( P < 0.05) motionless with the approaching human compared to non-stroked calves (SS − H), suggesting a persistent effect. However, this effect was not reproduced on the other behavioural criteria recorded (e.g., duration of human contact or docility score). In the different tests and at the different ages, the docility scores of the dams were significantly correlated (up to 0.7, P < 0.01) with behaviour towards humans shown by stroked calves but not non-stroked calves (SS − H). Our results suggest that additional human contact at early age, but not duration of the separation from the dam, could be beneficial for the human–animal relationship, but only for calves born to docile dams.