Value of respiratory variations of right ventricular dimension in the identification of small atrial septal defects (secundum type) not requiring surgery: An echocardiographic study

In search of reliable criteria that could help differentiate insignificant atrial septal defects (ASDs) from those with a large shunt, M-mode echocardiograms of three groups of patients were studied retrospectively: group I = 10 normal children (mean age 5.7 years); group II = 10 patients (mean age 7 years) with small ASD in whom the decision was taken not to proceed to surgical closure, based on hemodynamic and angiographic criteria; and group III = 15 patients (mean age 7 years) with an “operable” shunt, who underwent corrective surgery. The results showed that right ventricular end-diastolic dimensions during expiration (RVDDE) were increased in all patients in group III but were normal in only 3 of the 10 patients in group II. A normal septal movement was found in all patients in groups I and II but also in five patients in group III. The variation in right ventricular diastolic dimension with respiration (RVDVR) was always normal in group II. However, in group III all patients but one had a small RVDVR (less than 6%). It was concluded that a normal RVDDE is very specific (100%) but not sensitive (30%), a normal septal movement is very sensitive (100%) and moderately specific (70.6%), and a normal RVDVR is both very sensitive (100%) and specific (94.4%) as a criterion for identification of small ASDs not requiring surgery.