Extreme Inverted Trophic Pyramid of Reef Sharks Supported by Spawning Groupers

The extent of the global human footprint [1] limits our understanding of what is natural in the marine environment. Remote, near-pristine areas provide some baseline expectations for biomass [2, 3] and suggest that predators dominate, producing an inverted biomass pyramid. The southern pass of Fakarava atoll—a biosphere reserve in French Polynesia—hosts an average of 600 reef sharks, two to three times the biomass per hectare documented for any other reef shark aggregations [4]. This huge biomass of predators makes the trophic pyramid inverted. Bioenergetics models indicate that the sharks require ∼90 tons of fish per year, whereas the total fish production in the pass is ∼17 tons per year. Energetic theory shows that such trophic structure is maintained through subsidies [5–9], and empirical evidence suggests that sharks must engage in wide-ranging foraging excursions to meet energy needs [9, 10]. We used underwater surveys and acoustic telemetry to assess shark residency in the pass and feeding behavior and used bioenergetics models to understand energy flow. Contrary to previous findings, our results highlight that sharks may overcome low local energy availability by feeding on fish spawning aggregations, which concentrate energy from other local trophic pyramids. Fish spawning aggregations are known to be targeted by sharks, but they were previously believed to play a minor role representing occasional opportunistic supplements. This research demonstrates that fish spawning aggregations can play a significant role in the maintenance of local inverted pyramids in pristine marine areas. Conservation of fish spawning aggregations can help conserve shark populations, especially if combined with shark fishing bans. [Display omitted] •Extremely high shark biomass in Fakarava pass produces an inverted trophic pyramid•Prey inhabiting the pass do not satisfy shark energy requirements•Subsidies are brought directly to sharks via fish spawning aggregations•Concentrating local energy is a new mechanism for maintaining inverted pyramids Mourier et al. report extremely high shark biomass in pristine Fakarava pass, French Polynesia, producing an inverted trophic pyramid. To escape such constraints, predators typically forage long range on multiple pyramids. This study presents a new mechanism in which subsidies directly come to predators in the form of spawning aggregations.