MEDIA AND COURT: CONSIDERATIONS CONCERNING DEVELOPMENT, MORALITY, DIGNITY AND THE JUDGES FROM BEER ADVERTISEMENTS/A MIDIA NO BANCO DOS REUS: CONSIDERACOES SOBRE MAGISTRADOS, DESENVOLVIMENTO, DIGNIDADE E MORALIDADE A PARTIR DE PROPAGANDAS DE CERVEJA

The theme of this essay is the Media, the Judges, dignity and the morality, and it seeks to establish the need to rethink the role of judges as moral guardians of legal and social demands. Starting by Jeremy Waldron's criticized dogma, that the judges would be the most suitable individuals to s...

Ausführliche Beschreibung

Gespeichert in:
Bibliographische Detailangaben
Veröffentlicht in:Quaestio iuris 2017-11, Vol.10 (4), p.2570
Hauptverfasser: Grubba, Leilane Serratine, Oliveira, Amanda Muniz
Format: Artikel
Sprache:spa
Schlagworte:
Online-Zugang:Volltext
Tags: Tag hinzufügen
Keine Tags, Fügen Sie den ersten Tag hinzu!
Beschreibung
Zusammenfassung:The theme of this essay is the Media, the Judges, dignity and the morality, and it seeks to establish the need to rethink the role of judges as moral guardians of legal and social demands. Starting by Jeremy Waldron's criticized dogma, that the judges would be the most suitable individuals to solve morally controversial issues, we turn to two court decisions concerning similar cases: beer commercials with offensive potential to female dignity. The main objective is to analyze the problems involved in the dogma. In order to do so, methodologically, we will investigate the roll of Media and its language, and later on, analyze the idea that the judged are more suitable to solve legal and social issues concerning morality. In the end, we question the problem of mixing individual morality in legal issues concerning human rights.Keywords: Law; Media; Judges; Morality; Female Dignity.O presente ensaio tem como tema a midia, o Poder Judiciario, a dignidade e a moral, e procura demonstrar a necessidade de se repensar o papel dos juizes como guardioes morais das demandas juridicas e sociais. Tendo como ponto de partida o dogma criticado por Jeremy Waldron, de que os juizes seriam os individuos mais indicados para resolver questoes moralmente controversas, nos voltaremos a duas decisoes judiciais relativas a casos semelhantes: propagandas de cerveja com potencial ofensivo a dignidade feminina. O objetivo principal e problematizar as questoes oriundas do dogma mencionado. Para tanto, metodologicamente, sera analisado o papel da midia e de sua linguagem para, apos, questionar a ideia de que o Poder Judiciario esta apto a deliberar moralmente sobre questoes controversas. Por fim, levanta-se a problematica do envolvimento da moralidade individual em questoes juridicas relativas aos Direitos Humanos.Palavras-chave: Direito; Midia; Poder Judiciario; Moral; Dignidade Feminina.
ISSN:1516-0351
DOI:10.12957/rqi.2017.28067