Key data store garbage collection and multipart object management

In an example embodiment, a method comprises determining that a multipart upload request to upload a data object in separate object parts has been received by an object storage service; generating temporary keys for the separate object parts of the data object; storing the temporary keys in a temporary key data store; generating, based on the temporary keys, a multipart key entry for the data object, the multipart key entry comprising a multipart key that contains an object identifier identifying the data object and an inverse timestamp; and inserting the multipart key entry in a persistent key data store storing an ordered set of key entries in a position determined by the object identifier and the inverse timestamp.