Data storage and retrieval in redundant storage systems

A computing resource service receives a request to retrieve data, wherein fulfillment of the request involves retrieval of representations of the data from a number of datastores maintained by the service. The service transmits requests to individual datastores to retrieve the representations of the data. Before all responses to these requests are received, the service evaluates any received responses to determine whether a quorum has been reached with regard to the representations of the data. If so, the service consolidates the representations of the data and provides the consolidated data to fulfill the request.