Contrasting Toxicity of a Fomesafen-Based Herbicide on Three Freshwater Phytoplanktonic Species

Pesticides leaching and run-off to nearby freshwater sources are a major ecological concern. The emergence of herbicide-resistant weeds led to the increased usage of fomesafen, a diphenyl ether herbicide inhibiting protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPO). This recent rise in demand and use for this molecule invariably increases the chance of this herbicide entering freshwater environments and affecting non-target organisms. However, there is still a lack of information in the literature regarding the impact of this herbicide on the physiology of freshwater phytoplankton. This study aimed to determine the impact of five concentrations (0, 5, 10, 40, 320 µg · L−1) of a fomesafen-based herbicide (Reflex®) on the physiology of two species of green microalgae (Raphidocelis subcapitata FACHB-271; Chlamydomonas snowii) and one cyanobacterial species (Microcystis aeruginosa CPCC 632). While physiological biomarkers (growth, photosynthesis, pigment content, oxidative stress and morphology) of R. subcapitata were significantly affected by the fomesafen treatments, no significant effects were observed in the physiology of C. snowii and M. aeruginosa. We hypothesize that this difference in fomesafen resistance is most likely due to intracellular morphological and genetic differences between species. Modeling of fomesafen uptake in R. subcapitata showed that alteration of cell biovolume is unlikely to be an efficient mechanism modulating fomesafen toxicity and that potential fomesafen efflux or breakdown would need to be very fast (and operate at a high energy cost) in order to protect against uptake and toxicity. This study provides new insights into the sensitivity of different algae species toward fomesafen as well as the associated cellular toxicity mechanisms.