Differential dose-response patterns of intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes under sub-lethal antibiotic exposure

Although antibiotics are one of the most significant factors contributing to the propagation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), studies on the dose-response relationship at sub-lethal concentrations of antibiotics remain scarce, despite their importance for assessing the risks of antibiotics in the environment. In this study, we constructed a series of microcosms to investigate the propagation of intracellular (iARGs) and extracellular (eARGs) ARGs in both water and biofilms when exposed to antibiotics at various concentrations (1–100 μg/L) and frequencies. Results showed that eARGs were more abundant than iARGs in water, while iARGs were the dominant ARGs form in biofilms. eARGs showed differentiated dose-response relationships from iARGs. The abundance of iARGs increased with the concentration of antibiotics as enhanced selective pressure overcame the metabolic burden of antibiotic-resistant bacteria carrying ARGs. However, the abundance of eARGs decreased with increasing antibiotic concentrations because less ARGs were secreted from bacterial hosts at higher concentrations (100 μg/L). Furthermore, combined exposure to two antibiotics (tetracycline & imipenem) showed a synergistic effect on the propagation of iARGs, but an antagonistic effect on the propagation of eARGs compared to exposure to a single antibiotic. When exposed to antibiotic at a fixed total dose, one-time dosing (1 time/10 d) favored the propagation of iARGs, while fractional dosing (5 times /10 d) favored the propagation of eARGs. This study sheds light on the propagation of antibiotic resistance in the environment and can help in assessing the risks associated with the use of antibiotics. [Display omitted] •eARGs were dominant in water, while iARGs were dominant in biofilms.•iARGs positively correlated with the concentration of antibiotic exposure.•eARGs negatively correlated with the concentration of antibiotic exposure.•Combined antibiotics’ exposure enhanced iARGs but decreased eARGs abundance.•One-time dosing favored iARGs while fractional dosing favored eARGs propagation.