Investigation of Drive Performance of Motors in Electric Loaders with Unequal Transmission Ratios—A Case Study

Research on electric wheel loaders (EWLs) has predominantly focused on battery management, hybrid technologies, and energy recovery. However, the influence of motor types and drivetrains on the drive performance of EWLs has received little attention in previous studies. This case study addresses this gap by examining different EWL configurations and analyzing the drive theory and force requirements by integrating classic vehicle theory with EWL-specific characteristics. The study compares an original EWL, equipped with Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (PMSMs) on both the front and rear axles with identical transmission ratios of 22.85, to a modified EWL, which features a Switched Reluctance Motor (SRM) on the front axle and a transmission ratio of 44.05. Walking and shoveling tests were conducted to evaluate performance. The walking test results reveal that, at motor speeds of 200 rpm, 400 rpm, and 600 rpm, energy consumption in R-drive mode is 68.56%, 71.88%, and 74.87% of that in F-drive mode when two PMSMs are used. When an SRM is applied with a transmission ratio of 44.05, these values shift to 73.90%, 70.35%, and 67.72%, respectively. This demonstrates that using the rear motor alone for driving under walking conditions can yield greater energy savings. The shoveling test results indicate that distributing torque according to wheel load reduces rear wheel slippage, and the SRM with a transmission ratio of 44.05 delivers sufficient drive force while operating within a high-efficiency speed range for the EWL.