Technical note: Do different projections matter for the Budyko framework?

The widely used Budyko framework defines the water and energy limits of catchments. Generally, catchments plot close to these physical limits, and Budyko (1974) developed a curve that predicted the positions of catchments in this framework. Often, the independent variable is defined as an aridity index, which is used to predict the ratio of actual evaporation over precipitation (Ea/P). However, the framework can be formulated with the potential evaporation as the common denominator for the dependent and independent variables, i.e., P/Ep and Ea/Ep. It is possible to mathematically convert between these formulations, but if the parameterized Budyko curves are fit to data, the different formulations could lead to differences in the resulting parameter values. Here, we tested this for 357 catchments across the contiguous United States.