Medio siglo de cribado neonatal en España: Evolución de los aspectos éticos, legales y sociales (AELS). Parte I, aspectos éticos
Newborn screening for treatable diseases began in Spain in 1968. During this half century important changes political, social and technologic have occurred. Present work divided in three parts analyzes the evolution of ethical, legal and social issues (ELSIs), respectively Part I, Part II and Part I...
Gespeichert in:
Veröffentlicht in: | Revista española de salud pública 2021 (95) |
---|---|
Hauptverfasser: | , , , , , , , , |
Format: | Artikel |
Sprache: | spa |
Schlagworte: | |
Online-Zugang: | Volltext |
Tags: |
Tag hinzufügen
Keine Tags, Fügen Sie den ersten Tag hinzu!
|
Zusammenfassung: | Newborn screening for treatable diseases began in Spain in
1968. During this half century important changes political, social
and technologic have occurred. Present work divided in three parts
analyzes the evolution of ethical, legal and social issues (ELSIs),
respectively Part I, Part II and Part III.
Part I, ethical issues is aimed to the consideration of principles
of biomedical and public health ethics applied to newborn
screening programs in relationship with its technical characteristics
which are very relevant for ethical deliberation: newborn
screening is a genetic screening; only a small number of newborns
suffers disease included in the program and therefore will receive
benefits; screening applies to asymptomatic and vulnerable newborns
that cannot exerts his/her autonomy and therefore must be
protected; evaluation of results is challenging; as any public health
intervention may have adverse consequences.
Chronological evolution states a first period 1968-2000 beginning
with the principles of Wilson - Jungner, the first paper containing
ethical principles that can be applied to newborn screening,
introducing decision criteria and good practices in public health
policies. A second period 2000-2010 markedly influenced by the
emergency of tandem mass spectrometry that promotes a sudden
expansion of programs and the consequent ethic debate, Wilson-
Jungner principles are reviewed and appear relevant ethical documents
in USA, Europe and also in Spain with the first’s papers on
ethical recommendations for screening programs. A third period
2000-2019 examines the incorporation of new criteria in programs
implementation and the continuous technological challenges with
newborn genome sequencing already in the horizon.
It will be very important for the future of the newborn screening
programs the development of ethical, legal and social issues
in parallel with technological challenges. And that health authorities
places diseases and not technologies as central subject, acting
in children best interest, looking for a positive balance of benefits/
risks and observing the relevant and well acknowledged principles
for genetic screening of proportionality, respect for autonomy
and justice.
El cribado neonatal de enfermedades endocrino-metabólicas
tratables se inició en España el 1968, y durante el medio siglo que
ha transcurrido desde entonces hemos vivido importantes cambios,
políticos, sociales y tecnológicos. Esta serie, dividida en tres
partes, analiza la |
---|---|
ISSN: | 1135-5727 |