Genetic variation and productivity of Populus trichocarpa and its hybrids. VII. Two-year survival and growth of native black cottonwood clones from four river valleys in Washington

A common-garden study of Populus trichocarpa Torr. and Gray was initiated in 1985 when clonal material from 128 trees was collected from sites distributed along two mesic (Hoh and Nisqually) and two xeric (Dungeness and Yakima) river valleys. This material was grown for 1 year at Puyallup, Wash. In spring 1986, cuttings from this material were used to establish two replicate plantations, one at Puyallup and one at Wenatchee, Wash. Over the 2 year period, trees were assessed for survival, damage, and growth. Two-year survival was 86% at Puyallup and 59% at Wenatchee; survival was higher for mesic-origin trees at both sites. At Wenatchee, mortality was mainly due to a droughty soil and hot, dry climate in the first year, and damage was due to the tarnished plant bug (Lygus spp.), field voles (Microtus spp.), and grasshoppers (Family Acrididae). At both locations, Melampsora occidentalis Jacks. leaf rust was found mainly on trees originating from Yakima. Mean 2-year height and diameter at Puyallup were 457 cm and 40 mm, respectively; corresponding values at Wenatchee were 320 cm and 29 mm. At Puyallup, 2-year stem volume (diameter2 X height) decreased significantly in this order: Nisqually (13 500 cm3) = Hoh > Dungeness > Yakima (4700 cm3). Within the Nisqually trees, clones from lower, milder climate elevations grew more than those from the upper elevations. The reverse was true for the Yakima trees, presumably because the lower elevation trees are adapted to an arid climate and are very susceptible to Melampsora rust. At Wenatchee, high microsite heterogeneity masked much of the genetic variation. The genetic variance component (among rivers, sites, and clones) for stem volume at Puyallup increased from 27 to 51% over the second year. In analyses of each river valley, genetic components (elevational group and clone) were also high at 27-63%; however, for the Yakima trees, the elevational group variance (40%) was much larger than for the other valleys (0-7%).