EveCheck: An Event-Driven, Scalable Algorithm for Coherent Shared Memory Verification

Cache coherence and relaxed memory consistency challenge the design verification of multicore chips. The well-known self-checking approach based on litmus tests has been successful in uncovering design errors, but it leads to limited coverage. That is why random or directed test generation approaches are used for proper coverage control, but they require a specialized checker to verify shared memory behavior. Unfortunately, the inference-based checkers that provide guarantees against false positives and false negatives are not scalable with core count (unless some memory orderings are known beforehand). On the other hand, scoreboard-based checkers are scalable, but do not offer guarantees against false diagnosis. This article proposes an event-driven algorithm that is scalable without renouncing verification quality, because it relies on direct partial order verification, on-the-fly detection of improper memory orderings, exploitation of extended observability not hampered by design optimizations, and agnostic handling of store atomicity at the implementation level. We compared the new algorithm with two scoreboard-based and one inference-based checker reported in the literature. EveCheck often reaches full error detection with half the test size required by the other checkers, has superior verification quality, and less sensitivity to test generation parameters. Its effort to detect errors was one order of magnitude inferior as compared to the inference-based checker. It did not raise false positives in correct designs, and it was able to discover all the errors studied in faulty designs.