Can Post-Subduction Porphyry Cu Magmas Form by Partial Melting of Typical Lower Crustal Amphibole-Rich Cumulates? Petrographic and Experimental Constraints from Samples of the Kohistan and Gangdese Arc Roots

Sulfide-rich hydrous arc cumulates in the lower crust are considered a likely source for porphyry Cu-forming magmas in post-subduction settings. However, it remains controversial whether or not post-subduction porphyry Cu magmas can be produced by partial melting of lower crustal arc cumulates. Here we performed detailed petrographic and geochemical studies on exhumed lower to middle crustal cumulates from the Gangdese and Kohistan arc sections, and then conducted partial melting experiments of the Gangdese sulfide-rich lithologies at 1.5 GPa and 800°C–1150°C using a piston cylinder press. Both the Gangdese and the Kohistan arc-root samples formed as cumulates in the lower to middle crust, but the Kohistan samples were subsequently brought into the garnet stability field during the India–Eurasia continental collision. Most of the Gangdese samples contain relatively high abundances of magmatic sulfides preserved in the form of Cu-poor monosulfide solid solution. In contrast, most of the Kohistan samples contain very low abundances of Cu-rich sulfides preserved as inclusions in garnet, probably due to intense metamorphic dehydration and up to 2 wt% partial melting in the garnet stability field. The original magmatic sulfides at Kohistan appear to have been removed mainly by metamorphic fluids rather than by partial melts, as the arc-root samples could have experienced only very low degree of partial melting and the sulfur solubility in experimentally produced partial melts is low (≤0.1 wt%) even at oxygen fugacities two log-units above the fayalite-magnetite-quartz buffer. Furthermore, the experimental partial melts contain much less K2O, MgO, Cl and ±S than typical post-subduction porphyry Cu-forming magmas. Hence, we conclude that the role of sulfide-rich arc cumulates in the formation of post-subduction porphyry Cu magmas has been severely overestimated.