Recognition of the T-Arm of tRNA by tRNA (m5U54)-Methyltransferase Is Not Sequence Specific

tRNA (m5U54)-methyltransferase (RUMT) catalyzes the methylation of U54 of tRNAs. In contrast to enzymes which recognize a particular tRNA, RUMT recognizes features common to all tRNAs. We have shown that these features reside in the T-arm of tRNA and constructed a minimal consensus sequence for RUMT recognition and catalysis (Gu et al., 1991b). Here, we have mutated each conserved T-loop residue and conserved T-stem base pair to bases or base pairs which are not observed in Escherichia coli tRNA. The substrate specificity of RUMT for 30 in vitro synthesized T-arm mutants of tRNAPhe and 37 mutants of the 17-mer analog of the T-arm derived from tRNA1 Val was investigated. A 2−5 base pair stem was essential for recognition of the T-arm by RUMT, but the base composition of the stem was unimportant. The 7-base size of the T-loop maintained by the stem was essential for RUMT recognition. For tRNA, most base substitutions in the 7-base loop did not eliminate RUMT activity, except for any mutation of the methyl acceptor U54 and the C56G mutation. The effect of base and base pair mutations on k cat or the rate of methylation by RUMT was more striking than the effect on the K d for binding to RUMT. In comparison with mutations in the T-loop of intact tRNA, base mutation in the T-loop of the 17-mer T-arm had a more deleterious effect on binding and methylation. Surprisingly, recognition of tRNA by RUMT appears to reside in the three-dimensional structure of the seven-member T-loop rather than in its primary structure.