A decision problem for varieties of commutative semigroups

For a first order formula P: ∀x1, …, ∀xn, ∃y1, …, ∃ym (u(x1, …, xn, y1, …, ym) ≡ v(x1, …, xn, y1, …, ym)) where u and v are two words on the alphabet {x1, …, xn, y1, …, ym}, and a finite set E of semigroup identities with xy ≡ yx in it, we prove that it is decidable whether P follows from E, that is whether all the semigroups in the variety defined by E satisfy P.