Plant-functional traits drive insect herbivory in a tropical rainforest tree community

[Display omitted] •Clustering of functional traits in tropical woody plant species shed light on the ecology and evolution of plant herbivore interactions.•Suites of functional traits define three defense syndromes: low nutrition, defense and tolerance to herbivory.•The low nutritional quality syndrome seems to be the ancestral antiherbivore defense syndrome in woody tropical rain forest species.•Tolerance and defense syndromes cluster closely phylogenetically related species. A set of species, not linked by close ancestry, with similar functional responses to selective pressures, is known as a functional group or response syndrome. Some studies have investigated antiherbivore plant defenses in the context of defense syndromes, with contrasting results. We analyze how the assembly of leaf-functional traits and wood density can explain insect herbivory in 69 woody species in a tropical rain forest in southern Mexico. In addition, we used a phylogenetic hypothesis to address whether the observed syndromes were at least in part driven by ancestry. Three functional groups of woody plants were detected and related to 1) low nutritional quality, 2) resistance, and 3) tolerance to herbivory. Herbivory tolerant species presented the highest damage by herbivores, which is concordant with theoretical expectations and other empirical observations. In contrast, herbivory in the defensive resistance and low nutrition syndromes were 35 % and 55 % lower than in herbivory tolerant species, respectively. Taxa in the defensive resistance syndrome were significantly clustered based on the net relatedness index (NRI) and the nearest taxon index (NTI). In contrast, in the other two syndromes, the NRI showed a random structure but opposed deviations from random expectations in the NTI. Taxa in the low nutritional quality syndrome were over-dispersed in the phylogeny, while tolerant species appeared clustered. This evidence suggests that the low nutritional quality syndrome may represent the ancestral antiherbivore defense of woody plants in the tropical rain forest. In contrast, the tolerance and defensive resistance syndromes included clades of recent diversification.