Correlation between surface/bulk properties and electrochemical cycling performance of pure silicon anode materials

State-of-the-art lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) employ silicon (Si)-graphite composite anode with just a few percentages of Si active material, whose cycle-life relies on a stable solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer. As a number of various types of industrial Si active materials are currently available, an informative guideline based on the material properties and resultant cycling performance of different pure Si (i.e., without graphite) anode materials is strongly needed for material selection. The present study provides for the first time the correlation among material's surface and bulk properties, the SEI formation behavior, and cycling behavior of highly loaded pure Si anodes (2.3 mAh cm−2) prepared from four different industrial active materials, which are SiOx, carbon-coated Si, and bare Si with submicron and micron sizes. Commercial electrolyte with 10 wt% fluoroethylene carbonate additive is used for electrochemical performance evaluation. Based on solid-state NMR, XPS, and electrochemical analysis results, SiOx is determined to be relatively beneficial for practical applications beyond Si materials, in the aspects of high structural and particle morphology stability, cycling stability and suppressed interfacial resistance. This is mainly because of more effective accommodation of volume change of Si and oxygen-enriched surface (SEI) stability. The data give insight into the rational design of well-working Si-dominant or pure Si anodes for high energy density LIBs. •Comparison studies of pure Si anode active materials comprising SiOx, carbon-coated Si, and Si at submicron and micron sizes.•Correlation among material properties, SEI formation and electrochemical cycling behavior of pure Si anodes (2.3 mAhcm−2).•SiOx as a beneficial anode active material for practical application determined by cycle performance and analysis results.•Guideline for the selection of pure Si anode active material for Si-dominant or pure Si anodes for high energy density LIBs.