Impact of forest degradation and reforestation with Alnus and Quercus species on soil quality and function in northern Iran

•Deforestation decreased most microbial activities related to soil C and N cycles.•Reforestation improved soil quality and function after 30 years.•Alnus did not affect litter N but significantly enhanced litter P.•Reforestation with Quercus was more efficient than Alnus in recovering soil function.•A higher litter input under Quercus was more important than better litter quality of Alnus for soil recovery. Forest degradation causes soil carbon losses and affects soil C and N cycling. However, it is not clear how reforestation of degraded areas with different species affects soil and ecosystem restoration, particularly in northern Iran. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of forest degradation and reforestation with two contrasting species: Alnus and Quercus as N2-fixing and non N2-fixing tree species, respectively, on soil quality and function after 30 years in the northern Iran region. We selected four forest stands: Carpinus betulus-Parrotia persica natural forest (NF), Alnus subcordata (AP) and Quercus castaneifolia (QP) plantations as rehabilitated areas, and a degraded natural forest (DNF). We examined the main litter and soil chemical properties and soil C and N microbial fractions. Litter and soil physico-chemical properties and microbial activity differed among land covers. As expected, deforestation caused a decrease in most soil C and N fractions as well as in soil microbial activity with an increase in metabolic quotient-qCO2. The plantation with Quercus spp. improved substrate induced respiration, as well as microbial biomass carbon and dissolved organic carbon compared to the Alnus plantation, whereas mineral N was similar in the natural site and the Alnus plantation. Although forest plantations had not reached the same values of microbial activity as the natural forest soils, soil C and N fractions were similar to the natural site after 30 years. The findings of this study support the importance of preserving natural forests for soil conservation. In addition, employing of N2 fixing trees such as Alnus spp. or, Quercus spp., suitable native broadleaved species, is proposed for the rehabilitation of degraded natural forests. Although both forest plantations led to soil recovery after 30 years, Quercus plantations were more efficient in restoring microbial communities than Alnus plantations indicating that litter quantity is more important than litter quality for soil recovery.