Productivity-induced redox transition within the Niobrara formation, western Interior seaway, Colorado

Deposition of organic rich shale/marl within the Niobrara Formation during the Coniacian to Santonian Ocean anoxic event (OAE 3) within the Western Interior Seaway presents a unique record of variable organic carbon burial under a greenhouse climate. In order to understand the mechanisms behind the changes from low to high organic carbon burial, and how this high burial rate was sustained for over 3 Ma, productivity within the surface waters and subsequent preservation of organic matter within the sediments were investigated in this study. Based on the multiproxy approach adopted herein, the sedimentary record of the Niobrara Formation in northern Colorado can be separated into two distinct intervals: Interval 1 and Interval 2. Interval 1 is bioturbated, organic lean and oxic, with low to moderate trace metal enrichment except for Mn. Interval 2 is laminated, organic-rich, more enriched in trace metals U, V and Mo, and less enriched in Mn, typical of anoxia during deposition. The transition from oxic to anoxic conditions coincides with greater enrichments in TOC, Cu and Ni, suggesting enhanced productivity is associated with redox transitions within the Niobrara Formation. These local changes in productivity and redox conditions are sudden and coincide with recurring iron (Fe) and phosphorus (P)-rich bentonites, evidence of ash deposition that could have enhanced nutrient supply, productivity and accumulation of organic carbon. Consequently, perturbations of the global carbon cycle associated with OAE 3 were inferred to have occurred in Interval 2. High total Fe, total sulfur, Fe/Al, and trace metal enrichments in Interval 2 are intrinsically linked to prevalence of anoxic bottom-water conditions which enhanced burial of pyrite and organic matter. Results from productivity proxies and Fe–S–C ternary plots show that Fe limitation on pyrite formation under anoxic porewater enhanced organic carbon burial and preservation. This implies Fe enrichment within the sediments favored pyrite formation instead of organic matter sulfidization, leading to a complex relationship between S and organic carbon in the marine sediments during Niobrara deposition. •Multiproxy investigation of productivity and redox conditions separated the Niobrara Formation into two distinct intervals.•Identification of redox transition in lower Niobrara Formation.•Fe limitation on pyrite formation within Niobrara Formation.•Recurring ash bed depositions fertilized surface waters in mid to up