Environmental appraisals in outgroup cultural landscapes: The role of Muslim elements in urban settings

Cultural landscapes can contribute to positive environmental appraisals. However, previous studies focused on exposure to ingroup culture. Referring the debate in Europe on Muslim symbols in the public sphere, this study examines the effect of exposure to outgroup cultural cues on environmental appraisals. We compare environmental appraisals of participants from France, Germany, and the Netherlands after a simulated walk in an outgroup (Muslim) cultural landscape or a religiously-neutral environment. The effect of the Muslim setting was contingent on intolerance, with tolerant individuals reporting more positive environmental appraisals in the Muslim environment. However, this effect reversed as intolerance increased, and more intolerant individuals perceived the Muslim environment more negatively than the control. These findings offer an alternative view to the idea that the visibility of Muslim symbols in the public space has negative effects. Instead, we reveal a nuanced interplay between the urban environment, sociopolitical context and individual-level differences. •Cultural landscapes contribute to positive environmental appraisals among ingroups.•Effect of exposure to outgroup cultural cues on environmental appraisals is unclear.•We propose a multi-country simulated experimental walk in Muslim setting.•Social and political intolerance defined valence of appraisal.•Urban environment, sociopolitical context, individual differences generate nuanced interplay.