Pulsed exposure toxicity testing: Baseline evaluations and considerations using copper and zinc with two marine species

Methods to assess environmental impacts from episodic discharges on receiving water bodies need a more environmentally relevant and scientifically defensible toxicity test design. Many permittees are regularly required to conduct 96-h toxicity tests on discharges associated with events that are generally less than 24 h in duration. Current standardized methods do not adequately reflect these episodic discharge conditions at either the point of compliance nor as it mixes with the receiving environment. In order to evaluate more representative biological effects, an alternative toxicity approach is described incorporating pulsed exposures of effluents and subsequent transfer of test organisms to clean water for the remainder of the test. This pulsed exposure protocol incorporates a slight modification to USEPA Whole Effluent Toxicity (WET) chronic and acute methods for two marine species, purple sea urchin embryos, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, and juvenile mysid shrimp Americamysis bahia. Tests were performed with toxicants using standard static (96 h) and pulsed (6, 12, and 26 h) exposures. Following pulsed exposures, organisms were transferred to uncontaminated seawater for the remainder of the 96-h test period. Results for these species and endpoints indicated that the sensitivity of these species to copper and zinc were up to two orders of magnitude greater using standard continuous exposures compared to shorter pulsed exposures. Additional considerations assessed included timing of the onset of a pulse and latent effects following an exposure. This modified approach requires minimal modification to current standard methods and increases the realism to more accurately assess toxic effects resulting from episodic discharges. •Simple modifications to standard methods increase realism while still protective.•Sensitivity to Cu and Zn was higher for 96 h static vs. 6 or 12 h pulsed exposures.•Sea urchin embryos showed variable sensitivity to Zn up to 18 h post-fertilization.•96 h test period with pulsed exposures of 6–26 h captured latent effects to mysids.•Pulsed exposure toxicity testing is an environmentally relevant alternative method.