Giant cavernous hemangiomas: Diagnosis and surgical strategies

From January, 1972 to June, 1989, 51 patients with liver hemangiomas (32 females and 19 males, mean age 35 years) were evaluated for surgical treatment. Diameters of the masses were 5 cm to 20 cm (median 8.5 cm). Nine of the patients had already been treated for cancer. Twenty‐two (43.1%) of the 51 patients were symptomatic and 29 (56.9%) patients were asymptomatic. In 34 patients (66.7%) a definite diagnosis of hemangioma was made by scintiscan and/or ultrasound and/or computed tomography and/or angiography while in the remaining 17 (33.3%) patients the diagnosis was uncertain. The most common indications for resection were the presence of a symptomatic angioma, a symptomatic mass with an uncertain diagnosis, and/or lack of a definite pre‐operative diagnosis. Surgery was performed on 25 patients. Ten anatomic and 15 atypical resections or enucleations were performed. There were no postoperative deaths. Two further patients, operated for probable hemangioma, were found to have primary hepatic malignancies. In the 26 unresected patients, no complications were observed during follow‐up. In 3 patients, hemangioma enlargement was detected by ultrasound, but there were no symptoms. As cavernous liver hemangiomas are now more reliably diagnosed and their natural history is usually uneventful, surgery can be avoided in most cases. However, when a non‐resection policy is adopted, an exact diagnosis is essential in order to rule out primary or metastatic cancer. Surgical exploration and treatment should be limited to symptomatic or complicated cases as well as to patients with an uncertain diagnosis. Résumé De Janvier 1972 à Juin 1989, 51 patients ayant un hémangiome du foie (32 femmes et 19 hommes, âge moyen 35 ans) ont été examinés en vue d'une exérèse chirurgicale. Le diamètre de la lésion variait entre 5 et 20 cm (médiane = 8.5 cm). Neuf des patients avaient déjà été traités pour un cancer; 22/51 (43.1%) étaient symptomatiques alors que 29/51 (56.9%) étaient asymptomatiques. Chez 34/51 patients (66.7%), le diagnostic définitif d'hémangiome a été confirmé par scintigraphie et/ou échographie et/ou tomodensitométrie, alors que chez les 17 autres (33.3%), le diagnostic était uncertain. Les indications d'une résection les plus fréquentes étaient: la présence d'un angiome symptomatique, une masse symptomatique avec un diagnostic uncertain, et/ou absence de diagnostic définitif préopératoire. Vingt‐cinq des 51 patients ont été opérés. Il y a eu 10 résections anatomiqu