Comment on Improved CO2 Hydrogenation on Ni–ZnO/MCM-41 Catalysts with Cooperative Ni and ZnO Sites

A recent publication from Murthy et al.1 describes experiments in which they proposed the hypothesis that a bifunctional catalyst consisting of adlineated,2 nanometer-sized domains of Ni and ZnO, confined within the pores of MCM-41, hydrogenates carbon dioxide adsorbed on the ZnO using hydrogen atoms produced by the Ni-catalyzed dissociation of H2. The reanalysis of their data presented below suggests that the reaction rates they employed to test their hypothesis, when properly normalized, show little to no effect of bifunctionality. This closer inspection of their data raises the possibility that the observed effects may instead arise from experimental artifacts (e.g., different levels of conversion, finite rates of mass transport) or morphological correlations that were not considered by the authors.