The challenge-phage assay reveals differences in the binding equilibria of mutant Escherichia coli Trp super-repressors in vivo

The phenotypes of four mutant Escherichia coli Trp repressor proteins with increased activities have been examined in vivo using the challenge-phage assay, an assay based on a positive genetic selection for DNA binding. These proteins, which differ by single amino acid changes from the wild type (Glu13-->Lys, Glu18-->Lys, Glu49-->Lys and Ala77-->Val), require less L-tryptophan than wild-type repressor for activation in vivo, and are super-aporepressors. However, none of the four mutant repressors binds DNA in a corepressor-independent manner. Three of the four mutant repressors (with Glu-->Lys changes) are more active when complexed with tryptophan, and are superholorepressors. Challenge-phage assays with excess tryptophan rank the mutant holorepressors in the same order as determined by binding studies in vitro. Challenge-phage assays with limiting tryptophan reveal additional phenotypic differences among the mutant proteins. These results show that the challenge-phage assay is a robust assay for measuring the relative affinities of specific protein-DNA interactions in vivo.