On the validity of using semilogarithmic plots to determine initial velocities of enzyme-catalyzed reactions

It has been proposed ( Johnston & Diven, 1969 a ) that it is valid to use semilogarithmic (first-order) plots of the extent of reaction versus time for graphic determination of initial velocities of enzyme-catalyzed reactions. This proposition suggests the assumption that the initial velocity error expected to be introduced by the proposed procedure is smaller than or comparable to the error introduced by the customary graphic procedure. The latter is based on the assumption that the progress curves of enzyme-catalyzed reactions have an initial linear segment of sufficient duration to permit accurate determination of slope. The validity of the procedure proposed by Johnston and Diven is examined in this report. It is concluded that the procedure is applicable to a very small class of enzyme-catalyzed reactions and only under certain experimental conditions.