Detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in clinical specimens other than sputum by the Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD)--assessment of sample preparation methods and clinical evaluation

The Gen-Probe Amplified Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD) has been widely used as a rapid test for the identification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex in clinical samples, and several research groups have verified its clinical usefulness. However, most of the specimens they tested were sputum, and there have been few reports on other specimens. In particular, there have been no reports on assessments of methods of preparing samples other than sputum for the MTD. We assessed methods of preparing samples other than sputum and the influence of a local anesthetic and an anticoagulant that may be present in samples, and also evaluated the MTD as a means of detecting M. tuberculosis in pleural fluid, bronchial lavage cerebrospinal fluid, urine and ascitic fluid. 1. Assessment of three sample preparation methods, i.e., the NALC-NaOH method GuSCN-Diatom nucleic acid extraction method, and the ultrasonication method, revealed that the combination of the NALC-NaOH method and the ultrasonication method, widely used to prepare sputum samples, is also a valid method of preparing other samples. 2. The local anesthetic and the anticoagulant used clinically and remained in specimens did not affect the results of the MTD. 3. Seven (36.8%) of 19 pleural fluid samples from patients diagnosed as tuberculous pleurisy were positive of M. tuberculosis by the MTD, while five (27.8%) of 18 pleural fluid samples cultured for bacteria were positive for M. tuberculosis complex. None of the 20 pleural fluid samples from patients diagnosed as non-tuberculous pleurisy were positive for M. tuberculosis complex either by MTD or culture. 4. Eight (32.0%) of 25 bronchial lavage samples from patients diagnosed as pulmonary tuberculosis were positive for M. tuberculosis complex by the MTD, while 3 (12.0%) were positive by culture. None of the 18 bronchial lavage samples from patients diagnosed as non-tuberculous disease were positive for M. tuberculosis complex either by the MTD or culture. Based on these results, it is concluded that the MTD is a very useful method of detecting M. tuberculosis in clinical samples other than sputum because it is more sensitive than culture on Ogawa's egg medium in detecting M. tuberculosis complex in pleural fluid samples, bronchial lavage samples, and so on, with the same preparation method as used for sputum.