Gallstone recurrence after successful dissolution therapy

After successful dissolution therapy of cholesterol gallbladder stones bile again becomes supersaturated and recurrent gallstones may develop. Three different postdissolution treatments [500 mg ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) per day (N = 14, group I), 100 mg aspirin per day (N = 14, group II) and diet (N = 15, group III) versus a control group (no treatment, N = 15, group IV) aimed at preventing recurrence of gallstones were investigated in a prospective, randomized study in 58 gallstone patients (33 female, 25 male) after complete stone clearance. Bile samples (prior to dissolution therapy and at stone recurrence) were investigated for biliary cholesterol (C), phospholipids (PL), total bile acid concentration (BA), cholesterol saturation index (CSI), total lipid concentration (TLC), total biliary protein concentration (TP), and nucleation time (NT). In group IV multiple gallstones tended to recur more often than solitary stones (66.7% vs 16.7%) whereas in groups I-III only solitary stones recurred. Recurrent gallbladder stones were detectable in 10 patients (eight patients in group IV and one each in groups I and II, respectively) within one year after dissolution and in two patients (one each in groups III and IV, respectively) after 15 months. Furthermore, the probability of stone recurrence was significantly higher in untreated patients as compared to treated patients. In nine (group IV) of 12 patients with recurrent stones NT, C, CSI, PL, BA, TLC, TP, and bile acid spectrum remained nearly unchanged as compared to their pretreatment values, whereas in three (groups I-III) of 12 cases a decrease in C, CSI, and TP was observed during therapy. However, in each of these three patients, initial and after-treatment TP was significantly higher and NT shorter as compared to groups I-IV. Furthermore, in these cases (N = 3) NT was prolonged, whereas no significant changes were found in PL, BA, TLC, and bile acid spectrum. Recurrence of gallstones, which seems to occur more likely in patients with multiple stones as compared to solitary stones, will happen in the early stage after stone clearance, again causing biliary pain. UDCA, aspirin or diet will reduce the probability for recurrent stones after complete gallstone dissolution.