Clinical Utility of Bone Scan Features of Pleural Effusion: Sensitivity and Specificity for Malignancy Based on Pleural Fluid Cytopathology

Asymmetric chest activity with malignant and benign pleural effusions has been described in bone scans. However, the clinical utility of this finding is not elucible from the literature. We developed specific scintigraphic criteria for malignant pleural effusion and retrospectively assessed their sensitivity and specificity in a group of patient scans. Pleural fluid was submitted for cytopathology from 850 patients over a 5-yr period. Bone scans were done within 2 mo of the thoracentesis in 74 patients. As a consensus panel, we reread the scans and reviewed the cytology. The effusions were cytologically malignant in 25/74 patients (34%), indeterminate in 9/74 (12%) and benign in 40/74 (54%). Based on cytopathology, malignant pleural effusions were detected by bone scans with a sensitivity of 34%-50% and a specificity of 78%-89%; true sensitivity and specificity was somewhere in between averaging 42% (95% confidence interval 24%-60%) and 84% (95% confidence interval 73%-95%), respectively. The bone scan is frequently the first examination suggesting pleural metastasis, and when it is detected it should be pursued beyond pleural fluid cytology, if negative or indeterminate.