Unexplained Discrepancies in the Activity—Antigen Ratio in Congenital FX Deficiencies With Defects in the Catalytic Domain

Studies on molecular biology have considerably enhanced our understanding of congenital coagulation disorders but have failed so far to supply tools for an adequate classification of defects. In fact, mutations in the same domain may give rise to different phenotypes. Conversely, mutations in different domains, controlled by different exons, may cause similar patterns. The 37 kindreds with congenital factor X (FX) deficiency, known to have a defect in the catalytic domain, have been evaluated in an attempt to investigate the genotype—phenotype relation. Discrepant results were obtained because about half kindreds showed a type I pattern, namely a concomitant decrease in FX activity and antigen. The other half showed a type II pattern, namely a decrease in FX activity with a normal or near normal FX antigen. In a few instances, the allocation of the kindred either to type I or to type II defect could not be reached, due to the lack of information about the antigen. The comparison of the kindreds in which the same mutation has been discovered by different investigations is not always possible also for lack of information. The study analyzes the need to have a multipronged approach to the study of congenital FX deficiency. The indication of a mutation in a given domain does not provide clear information about the phenotype.