Assessing selection potential for Pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas) to a North American OsHV-1 μvar: Comparing two experimental assay methods

Ostreid Herpesvirus - 1 is a global threat to Pacific oyster aquaculture as catastrophic farm losses have occurred where OsHV-1 microvariants (μvars) become endemic. Genetic selection has proven effective for increasing survival to OsHV-1 exposure in multiple Pacific oyster breeding programs, but a novel μvar detected in San Diego Bay California has the potential to severely impact commercial aquaculture along the North American Pacific coast as no OsHV-1 μvar selected population is available commercially. Using a Molluscan Broodstock Program population descending from imports originating in the Miyagi prefecture (Japan), we evaluated the potential for genetic selection to improve survival against the San Diego Bay OsHV-1 μvar using a laboratory trial. Two experimental methods were evaluated, a common garden method where all 15 full-sibling families were pooled, and a petri dish method, where each family was confounded within replicate. No striking differences were found between experimental methods, and both experiments displayed high heritability (0.69 and 0.64) of the tested trait, a broad range of estimated breeding values, and a moderate prediction accuracy for the survival trait. A significant genotype-by-environment interaction occurred, highlighting variability in laboratory-based disease challenges, but the two experiments yielded similar results with minor to moderate re-ranking of mean family survival. Overall, the Miyagi population of Pacific oysters curated by the Molluscan Broodstock Program is a promising population to use for artificial selection to increase survival against San Diego Bay OsHV-1 μvar in attempts to obviate farm losses if the virus expands its currently isolated range. •High heritability and sufficient variation exist in a Pacific oyster population for genetic selection to improve survival after exposure to a OsHV-1 μvar from the North American Pacific coast.•Only nuanced differences exist between single family and common-garden experimental assay methods.